Learn / Climate guides

Smoke outside: what to ask before buying ventilation

On a smoky night, close up, filter the bedroom and expect CO2 to rise. When shopping, buy a system whose filters and controls you understand.

Jump to this week’s step

A portable air purifier with arrows circulating air inside a bedroom with the window closed.
A purifier filters room air. It does not bring outdoor air in.

At a glance

In this guide 5 sections

Ventilation brings outdoor air into the house. When that air is smoky, you need a plan for the bedroom tonight, and if you're shopping, a system whose filters and controls you understand. Settle the second part in the quote, before installation.

Smoke can reach homes covered by any of the six regional guides, including places far from the fire.

Fresh air and filtered air are different jobs

A household CO2 monitor does not measure smoke particles, so a low CO2 reading is not an all-clear for opening windows. Check outdoor fine particles (PM2.5) instead, and follow local air-quality and emergency guidance. A bedroom ventilation goal does not override it.

Closing up helps, but by how much varies from home to home. On smoke days in 2020, Bay Area buildings with indoor and outdoor sensors let in about a quarter of the outdoor fine particles on average, but about 1 in 5 let in more than 40%. Without an indoor particle sensor, you can't assume your home is typical.

Filters have limits too. Particle filters, even good ones, don't remove smoke's gases, and the evidence that air cleaners remove gases is limited. That's one reason health agencies advise cutting outdoor air during smoke rather than relying on filters alone.

Your bedroom on a smoky night

  1. Check outdoor air. Use AirNow's Fire and Smoke Map at airnow.gov, which shows a current-hour reading. When fine particles reach "Unhealthy for Sensitive Groups" (orange, AQI 101 or more, which starts at 35.5 µg/m³), close up.
  2. Close windows and doors. Skip window and door experiments until the smoke clears.
  3. Run a HEPA purifier in the bedroom, with the bedroom door shut. Size it by the smoke CADR on the label: at least two-thirds of the floor area in square feet (EPA's minimum), and better, equal to the floor area (AHAM's advice for wildfire smoke). By our arithmetic, a 12 × 14 ft bedroom with 8 ft ceilings needs at least about 110 cfm, and about 170 is better. Higher ceilings need a larger unit. Run it all the time, on the highest setting you can sleep with, and choose one that doesn't make ozone. In homes during wildfire smoke, portable HEPA cleaners cut indoor fine particles by about half to three-quarters.
  4. Central heating or air conditioning. If it has a fresh-air intake, set it to recirculate or close the outdoor damper. Use a MERV 13 filter or better if the system can handle it, and set the fan to On so it filters all the time. One caution: if return ducts run through an attic or crawlspace, leaks there can pull in unfiltered smoky air while the fan runs, so ask an HVAC contractor about yours.
  5. HRV or ERV. It depends on the filter on the outdoor-air side. With a snug-fitting MERV 13 filter there, running it on low is in line with Washington State's health department, which tells homes and other buildings with mechanical ventilation to close outdoor-air intakes during smoke unless MERV 13 or better filters are installed. Without one, set it to standby, recirculation or its lowest setting, whichever its manual allows. Some units ship with a basic MERV 8 filter, so check which one yours has.
  6. Kitchen and bath fans only while cooking or showering. Exhaust fans pull outdoor air in through cracks, unfiltered.
  7. Heat comes first. If the house gets too hot with everything shut, BC's Centre for Disease Control says heat is usually the bigger risk for most people. Health Canada suggests keeping indoor temperatures below 26 °C (79 °F). Run air conditioning on recirculate, or go somewhere cooler and cleaner.
  8. Expect CO2 to rise. Closed bedrooms in studies averaged roughly 1,300–2,400 ppm. In a sleep lab, nights near 1,000–1,300 ppm meant about 5–8 more minutes awake than nights near 770. Health Canada notes that bringing in outdoor air to lower CO2 during smoke also brings in smoke. That night isn't a normal night, so don't let it count when you judge the room or a fix: in the HouseExhale app, delete it (Air → your room → tap the night → Remove this night). If your Aranet4 or your phone recorded it, it can come back on the next read within about a week; remove it again if it does.
  9. When it clears, air out. When outdoor air is cleaner than indoors, even for a while, open the windows wide. By our estimate, that clears most of the CO2 build-up in about 15–20 minutes. Then restore normal ventilation, check or change filters (heavy smoke can load them quickly), and go back to ordinary bedroom checks.

A box-fan filter? A DIY filter made from a box fan and MERV 13 filters moves a lot of air cheaply, but it's loud: 58–67 dB at 5 feet in a lab test. California's air board says to use one only with extreme caution, never unattended, and only with a 2012-or-newer fan carrying a UL or Intertek mark. Overnight in a bedroom, use a certified purifier.

A ventilation cabinet, a removable filter and an instruction booklet in a utility space.
Follow your model’s manual for filter care, core cleaning and service.

Buy the filter path, not only a filter rating

Ask which filters the exact unit supports, how well they fit and seal, and whether the proposed airflow can be maintained with them installed. Do not put an unsupported high-resistance filter into a ventilator.

Some units ship with a basic MERV 8 filter and offer MERV 13 for the outdoor air as an option. The manufacturers we checked didn't publish airflow with the MERV 13 filter fitted, so ask for the delivered airflow with the filter you'll actually use.

The interagency Wildfire Smoke Guide and the CDC recommend MERV 13 or higher in central heating and cooling systems that can handle it. That is not blanket approval for MERV 13 in every HRV or ERV. Ask the installer to verify the ventilation unit separately. An appropriately sized portable air cleaner adds room particle filtration. EPA's filtration factsheet covers these options.

Ask the installer these five questions

  1. Where does outdoor air enter? Have them identify the intake and its control.
  2. How does this system operate during a smoke event? Request the manufacturer-supported procedure, including any standby, recirculation or low setting and how to reduce outdoor air temporarily.
  3. What happens to exhaust and pressure balance? Ask how the whole design behaves, including combustion appliances. Never block combustion flues or required combustion-air openings.
  4. Which filters can I buy locally? Request sizes, supported ratings (including whether a MERV 13 filter fits on the outdoor-air side, and the airflow with it), access instructions and an initial spare set.
  5. How does normal ventilation restart? Ask for clear instructions and any available reminder or automatic return feature.

Use these questions while shopping; they are not a rule to switch ventilation off in every smoke event. The right procedure depends on the system and its filter. The only agency smoke guidance we found written for homes with mechanical ventilation is Washington State's: close outdoor-air intakes unless MERV 13 or better filters are installed, and bring outdoor air back in when the smoke lets up.

Rehearse the controls on a clear day

Before smoke arrives, ask for a walkthrough using the installed controller. Check that you can find the setting that lowers or pauses outdoor air, that the display makes the operating state clear, and that you know which setting restores normal operation.

Keep the written instructions with the filter information, so you can find the right control quickly when smoke arrives.

Compare climate guides · Air purifier versus fresh air

This week: Start a smoke plan

  1. Bookmark AirNow's Fire and Smoke Map and your local air-quality and emergency guidance.
  2. Measure the bedroom's floor area in square feet. Check that your purifier's smoke CADR is at least two-thirds of it, and ideally equal to it.
  3. If you have an HRV or ERV, find which filter sits on the outdoor-air side, the setting that lowers or pauses outdoor air, and the one that restores normal operation. Keep spare filters and the instructions together.
  4. Decide where you could go that's cooler and cleaner if the house can't be kept safely cool. If you're shopping, take the five installer questions above to every quote visit.

Sources