Learn / Air basics

Air purifier or fresh air? What each one does for a stuffy bedroom

A filter and a supply of outdoor air solve different problems. This guide shows how to tell which job your room needs.

Jump to tonight’s step

A portable air purifier with arrows circulating air inside a bedroom with the window closed.
A purifier filters room air. It does not bring outdoor air in.

At a glance

In this guide 5 sections

An air purifier cleans the air that's already in the room: it pulls it through a filter and blows it back out. It doesn't bring any outside air in. The stale feeling in a closed bedroom by morning comes from too little outside air, and CO2 is the easiest way to see that build-up. The only thing that clears it is outside air. So a purifier and fresh air do different jobs, and a stuffy bedroom usually needs the second one.

What a purifier does

A portable air cleaner is a fan and a filter in a box. The common kind, often sold as HEPA, catches particles such as dust, pollen and smoke. Across 36 studies, HEPA cleaners cut particle levels in real rooms by roughly 20–80%.

Some purifiers add a second filter for gases, usually activated carbon, aimed at smells and chemical vapors. The federal wildfire-smoke guide for public health officials notes that a HEPA filter doesn't remove odor gases; that takes an activated-charcoal or potassium-permanganate stage. The same review of 36 studies found the evidence that air cleaners remove gases is limited.

Why it can't lower CO2

CO2 is the gas you breathe out. A purifier takes the room's air in and sends the same air back, minus some particles, so nothing from outside replaces it. Household purifier filters aren't designed to remove CO2, and the CO2 stays in the room until air from outside dilutes it. A fan blowing air around the room doesn't lower CO2 either, for the same reason: neither brings outdoor air in.

That's why you can run a purifier all night and still wake up to a close, stale room. If you have a CO2 monitor, you can see it for yourself: the night's number barely changes.

Health Canada's advice for lowering CO2 at home is all about air exchange: open windows once you've checked the outdoor air, run mechanical ventilation on a higher setting or for longer, and use the furnace fan to move air through the house. A purifier can run alongside those, but it doesn't replace them.

Side by side

Air purifierOutside air
What it doesFilters the air already in the roomReplaces stale room air with outdoor air
Lowers CO2NoYes
Catches dust, pollen and smoke particlesYes, with a particle filterOnly if the incoming air is filtered, and only as well as that filter
Works with the window shutYesThrough a ventilation system that serves the room
ExamplesPortable air cleaner, furnace filterCracked window, HRV or ERV, exhaust fan

When a purifier earns its place

Smoky days. On wildfire-smoke days, outside air is the problem, and a purifier in a closed bedroom is the most useful thing you can do for that room's air. In homes during wildfire smoke, portable HEPA cleaners cut indoor fine particles by about half to three-quarters (48–78% in seven Seattle homes) and cut the smoke getting indoors by about two-thirds on average in British Columbia homes. The EPA's clean-room factsheet says to keep windows and doors closed and, for the air cleaner, "Run it continuously on the highest fan setting." When air quality improves, even for a short time, it says to air the room out. Smoke and ventilation covers a smoky night step by step.

Sizing for smoke. Check the smoke CADR on the label. The EPA's minimum is a smoke CADR of at least two-thirds of the room's floor area in square feet. For wildfire smoke, AHAM, which certifies CADR ratings, recommends a smoke CADR equal to the floor area. By our arithmetic, a 12 × 14 ft bedroom with 8 ft ceilings needs at least about 110 cfm, and about 170 meets AHAM's wildfire rule. Rooms with higher ceilings need a larger unit.

Dust, pollen and pets. Particles a filter can catch.

Alongside fresh air. A balanced ventilation system (an HRV or ERV) filters the outdoor air it brings in, but how well depends on the filter. Some units ship with a basic MERV 8 filter and offer a finer MERV 13 filter for the outdoor air as an option. A purifier can still run in the room. They don't compete.

Skip any purifier that makes ozone on purpose: the 36-study review notes that some air-cleaning technologies produce harmful byproducts such as ozone. In a baby's room, keep the purifier's cord at least 3 feet from any part of the crib, as the US Consumer Product Safety Commission advises for corded products.

A bedroom window opened a little, with a blue airflow line passing through the gap.
A window gives outdoor air a direct route into the room.

What lowers CO2 in a bedroom

Outside air, in whatever form you can keep doing every night:

  • A window cracked, when weather, outdoor air, noise and security allow.
  • The ventilation you already have, on a higher setting, if it supplies or pulls air in the bedroom.
  • A balanced system with a fresh-air supply into the bedroom, when the free changes aren't enough.

Try one at a time and compare with your usual nights, with the door shut as usual. A night with the door open is a useful test (if it's lower, the room is short of outdoor air), but fire-safety researchers recommend sleeping with it closed. Free fixes to try first has the details, and the goal is 800 ppm or less, on average, while you sleep.

Tonight: See what your purifier does to CO2

  1. If you've measured a few usual nights already, keep everything the same: the same people, door, window and monitor spot.
  2. Run the purifier overnight the way you normally would, with the monitor at least 3 ft (1 m) from it so its airflow doesn't blow straight onto the sensor.
  3. In the morning, compare the night with your usual nights and with the 800 ppm goal.
  4. If the number barely moved, that's expected: the purifier was doing a different job. Try a fresh-air change next, such as a cracked window or your ventilation system on a higher setting.

Sources