Learn / Free fixes

Sleeping with the door closed: how to keep the air fresh anyway

Keep the closed door, find a route for outdoor air, give the air a way back out, and measure whether it reaches the bedroom.

Jump to tonight’s step

A bedroom with its door fully closed and an airflow ribbon coming from a wall supply vent.
A bedroom supply can deliver air while the door stays closed. Measure what reaches the room.

At a glance

In this guide 6 sections

Lots of people sleep with the bedroom door shut: for the kids, the dog, the noise or the light, or because fire-safety researchers recommend it. The trade-off is that a closed door cuts the bedroom off from the rest of the house, so the CO2 you breathe out builds up faster. You don't have to give up the closed door to fix that. You need another way for outside air to reach the room, and a way to check it's enough.

Why fire researchers say close it

The UL Fire Safety Research Institute's "Close before you doze" campaign recommends sleeping with the bedroom door closed, so that in a house fire a door stands between you and the fire. Its site, closeyourdoor.org, explains why.

There are good reasons to keep the door shut, so the goal is fresh air with the door closed.

What a closed door does to the air

With the door and window shut, the air you breathe out has few ways to leave. In new homes in Scotland, bedrooms with the window, door and small window-frame vents all shut averaged about 2,000 ppm through the night. Outdoor air is about 425, and the bedroom goal is 800 ppm or less, on average, while you sleep.

Opening the door helps less than people expect. In studies it lowered the night's average by about 20–45%. In Danish bedrooms it went from about 2,360 to 1,290 ppm. In the Scottish homes, bedrooms with only the door open still averaged about 1,550. And in the Danish test, the open door didn't measurably change sleep, while an open window improved it.

An open door shares the bedroom's air with the rest of the house; it doesn't bring outdoor air in. It helps only as far as the rest of the house is fresher. What matters is how much outdoor air reaches the room while you're in it: about 17–21 cfm (8–10 liters per second) for each person sleeping there, with larger adults at the upper end. Getting your bedroom to 800 explains the math.

Ways to get fresh air in with the door shut

Try these one at a time, for two or three nights each, and compare with your usual door-shut nights. Free fixes to try first has the expected effect of each and how many nights to give it.

A window cracked. The most direct source of outside air. In heating-season studies it lowered the night's average by about 40–60%. It depends on weather, outdoor air quality, noise and security, so it's rarely a year-round answer in a cold or hot climate. In a child's room, fit window stops so the window opens no more than 4 inches (about 10 cm), and don't rely on a screen to stop a fall, as the US Consumer Product Safety Commission advises.

Trickle vents, if your windows have them. These slot vents in the window frame lowered the night's average by about 20% in one study. Most US windows don't have them.

Your ventilation system, turned up. If you have an HRV, ERV or other system that supplies or pulls air in the bedroom, a higher setting lowered the night's average by about 40–55% in a field trial with doors and windows shut. Check first that it's running at all.

An en-suite bathroom fan, with the bathroom door open. The fan pulls air out through the bathroom, so air has to come into the bedroom to replace it: house air under the bedroom door, and outdoor air through leaks. In a test house, a 45 cfm en-suite fan running all night pulled about 15 cfm of house air through the closed bedroom but added little outdoor air. A hall bathroom's fan does little for a closed bedroom.

Check combustion safety first An exhaust fan's replacement air comes in wherever it can, including down a chimney. If a gas or oil furnace, boiler or water heater vents up a chimney, or you have a fireplace, ask a professional before running exhaust fans all night. A Florida Solar Energy Center report puts the start of spillage and backdrafting at about 5 to 10 pascals of suction compared with outdoors. Keep a CO alarm working.

The furnace fan from Auto to On. It moves air between the bedroom and the rest of the house through the ducts, even with the door shut. On most systems it brings in little or no outdoor air: in tracer-gas tests in tight houses, switching it on added almost none. In test houses with bedroom doors shut, though, cycling the central fan helped spread fresh air into closed bedrooms. It works best when the rest of the house is fresher than the bedroom, the bedroom has a supply vent, and the air has a way back out (below). It also uses electricity all night. If a gas water heater or furnace vents up a chimney, ask a pro first, and keep a CO alarm working.

Fewer sleepers in the room. Not always a choice, but worth knowing: two people add CO2 about twice as fast as one, and pets add some too. By our estimate from the physics, going from two sleepers to one typically lowers the night's average by about a third, and going from three to two by about a quarter. If the extra sleeper is a baby sharing your room, keep following safe-sleep advice: the AAP and the NHS both advise that a baby sleep in the parents' room for at least the first 6 months. Don't move a baby to another room to lower CO2.

Give the air a way back: transfer grilles and jump ducts

Air can only flow into a closed room as fast as it can flow out. When a supply vent blows into a closed bedroom that has no return, the room's pressure rises and the vent delivers less than it should. In Florida homes with the air handler running and doors shut, closed rooms averaged about 6 pascals above outdoors and 9 above the hallway.

A return path lets the air back out:

  • A door undercut. Usually too small on its own. Building Science Corporation says undercuts alone don't pass enough air, and the Building America Solution Center says an undercut usually needs to be 1.5 inches or more to work.
  • A transfer grille through the wall or above the door, or a jump duct from the bedroom ceiling to the hall. The Building America Solution Center's rule of thumb for existing homes is at least 1 square inch of open grille area for each cfm supplied to the room.

The aim is to keep a closed bedroom within about 3 pascals of the rest of the house. In one test house, transfer grilles over bedroom doors noticeably evened out how much fresh air reached each room, though less than opening the doors. No study has measured their effect on bedroom CO2.

A return path moves no air by itself. It's worth adding when the bedroom has a supply vent, or alongside the furnace fan on On. An HVAC contractor can measure the pressure across the closed door with the fan running to tell you whether the room needs one. It's a small project, not a free fix.

When the free changes aren't enough

If none of these gets your typical night to 800 or less, or you can't keep doing the one that does (a window in January, a fan too loud to sleep with), the reliable door-shut answer is a balanced ventilation system with a fresh-air supply into the bedroom itself. It brings outdoor air in and sends stale air out, recovering most of the heat, so the door can stay shut all year.

Unlike a fan that only pulls air out somewhere else in the house, a balanced system can be ducted to deliver fresh air to specific rooms. That's the part that matters here, though running new ducts in an existing home can be difficult and costly. Ask any installer how many cfm the bedroom will get on the setting it will actually run on, how air leaves the bedroom when the door is shut, and whether they'll measure it. Do I need an ERV? walks through the decision.

A monitor, pencil and notebook with spaces for three nights of observations.
The same setup and a short note make nights easier to compare.

Check it worked

Use the same monitor in the same spot, with the same people, and the door shut as usual. Give each change two or three nights. It counts as working when every night with it is below your usual night by at least 100 ppm, by 15% of how far your usual night sits above outdoor air, or by half the gap between your highest and lowest usual nights, whichever is largest. If the nights with it disagree, one more night decides, and then most nights, and the typical night with it, have to clear that bar. The HouseExhale app applies that rule and flags anything else that differed, so a lucky night doesn't fool you. Free fixes to try first explains it with examples.

Tonight: Test one door-shut change

  1. Keep the door shut the way you usually do, with the same people in the room and the monitor in its usual spot.
  2. Pick one change: a window cracked (if weather, outdoor air and security allow), your ventilation system on a higher setting, the furnace fan from Auto to On, or an en-suite bathroom fan with the bathroom door open.
  3. Write down the change and when you made it, then sleep as usual.
  4. Repeat it for two nights (three for the furnace fan or a bathroom fan), then compare each night with your usual door-shut nights and with the 800 ppm goal.

Sources